žižek archive
archive / stories / Einstein: curvature of space is primary, matter is its effect

Einstein: curvature of space is primary, matter is its effect

example · science-physics · retold in 4 talks

Einstein's move from special to general relativity, first matter curves space, then curvature is primary and matter is an effect, is used as a philosophical parallel to the shift from Kant to Hegel and to the Lacanian Real as formal impossibility.

2004: 1 talk 2009: 2 talks
≤2000talks it is told in, per year2026

As told 3

“Einstein's move to turn things around to say that no the curvature of the space is original and matter is just an effect of the curved space.”
“what we perceive as matter is just a kind of a reified fetishist misperception of a purely formal curvature of the space”
“Matter is nothing but an effect of the curving the space... in drive, object a is that which accounts for the Spannung.”

What it carries

one story, many jobs: the ideas this anecdote is deployed to argue, one tally mark per use (an idea page shows the same relation from the other end, as its shelf of stories)

Its cast and sources

populated by
alongside works

Every retelling 3

Einstein's move from special to general relativity, first matter curves space, then curvature is primary and matter is an effect, is used as a philosophical parallel to the shift from Kant to Hegel and to the Lacanian Real as formal impossibility., illustrating curved space as materialist dialectics,Kant to Hegel,Lacanian Real as formal impossibility
In the shift from special to general relativity, Einstein reversed the assumption that matter curves space: curvature is primordial, and matter is a reified misperception of formal curvature. Žižek uses this as a structural homology for the psychoanalytic and Marxist reversals he performs., illustrating curvature of space (psychoanalytic),trauma as virtual,purely formal materialism
Einstein first thought matter curves space, then had the more ingenious idea that matter is nothing but an effect of space curving. Žižek uses this to explain objet a in drive: not a positive substance but the minimal formal twist (curvature) that accounts for the Spannung., illustrating objet petit a,drive vs desire,Spannung