žižek archive
archive / ideas / Bartleby Politics ('I would prefer not to')

Bartleby Politics ('I would prefer not to')

The Event, Radical Politics & The Act · 15 concepts · 20 talks · 33.9 hours · 2008–2025

The political potential of Occupy Wall Street, defined not by demands but by the active, immobility-based occupation of public space, akin to Bartleby's refusal.

2008: 2 talks 2009: 1 talk 2010: 1 talk 2012: 2 talks 2014: 1 talk 2015: 1 talk 2016: 2 talks 2017: 3 talks 2020: 1 talk 2022: 1 talk 2024: 2 talks 2025: 3 talks
≤2000talks carrying this idea, per year2026

In his words 2

“sometimes when with your apparent, even critical activity, you keep things going on. the truly subversive thing is not to be violent, to do nothing.”
1:40:34 Left in Dark Times · Bartleby politics / subversive withdrawal
“The first thing to do — it's the first part of what I call Bartleby politics — is 'I prefer not to': we stop to dream your dream. This is not unimportant, this is extremely important.”
58:00 First as Tragedy, Then as Farce · Bartleby politics as first step of liberation

The stories that teach it

the jokes and anecdotes he reaches for when he works in this idea, ranked by how many of its talks they turn up in; each card is one story, with every retelling on its page

anecdote · in 3 of its talks

Obsessional neurosis in psychoanalysis

Žižek recounts being diagnosed as an obsessional neurotic during his own psychoanalysis; he would talk non-stop in sessions to prevent the analyst from asking a difficult question, not to achieve change but to ensure nothing would change.

example · in 2 of its talks

Clash of the Titans, Zeus complains that gods die when men stop praying

In the 2010 Clash of the Titans, Zeus (Liam Neeson) complains that if men stop praying to and celebrating the gods, the gods will cease to exist, illustrating the Lacanian point that God ex-ists only through belief.

example · in 2 of its talks

Slovenian Strikes

Žižek notes that in late 60s/70s Slovenia, when people had free weeks, they got into fights, suggesting that humans need obstacles and occupation, not just luxury.

example · in 2 of its talks

Obama and universal healthcare as symbolic struggle

Žižek uses Obama's healthcare debate as a model of a 'precise battle with universal connotation', not revolutionary but capable of shifting popular common sense about what the state can legitimately do.

anecdote · in 2 of its talks

Occupy Wall Street

Žižek defends Occupy Wall Street against claims it was just upper-middle-class students, arguing it formed the 'fertile ground' for Bernie Sanders and gradual political change, proving that failed attempts create the right moment.

anecdote · in 2 of its talks

Žižek and So On

Žižek jokes about the title of his guest's show, 'Žižek and So On,' interpreting 'so on' speculatively: he is merely a byproduct of the 'so on,' implying the host is the primary subject.

Where it comes up 20

22 moments located in the transcripts, click a timestamp to play from there

20:57 Bartleby politics
… So I'm here very open when people often tell me you are inconsistent, sometimes you are talking about Bartleby politics, sometimes you are talking about small rational steps, sometimes you sound like a kind of a Bakunin-like big revolution.
26:48 willing not
… And would you agree that one should apply here a wonderful Nietzschean distinction between a not-willing things and willing not.
Slavoj Žižek Interview2017-04-05 · 54:47
29:49 stasis
why I like what you said now because we have from the beginning this paradox you know that in ancient Greek already the word I think stasis has two opposite meanings it means static immobility and it means civil war and so on immobility stasis
26:18 freedom of non-movement
… -movement that is with the literal taking place of public space the protesters occupied their occupation so how would you characterize this freedom of non-movement in contrast to the prevailing conception of freedom as movement of open borders etc my god it almost sound that you are sorry to be so obsc …
~56:51 Bartleby politics
open-ended debates, these debates will have to coalesce not only around some new master signifiers but also in concrete answers to the old Leninist question: 'What is to be done?'" Can you um yeah develop that critique of Occupy? No again this is- now I …
Left in Dark Times2008-09-16 · 1:38:00
1:14:37 Bartleby politics
… in your book violence, basically one of the things you're saying is we should have a kind of bartleby politics.
48:30 Bartleby politics
… riendly way attacked me claiming that I am politically inconsistent, that sometimes I—I advocate the politics of what I call ironically the politics of Bartleby, "I would prefer not to." Sometimes I appear like waiting for a big terrorist act and so on, big revolution, and sometimes modest measures.

The company it keeps

thought with
alongside works

Nearest in meaning

Concepts in this idea 15