žižek archive
archive / ideas / Theory, Critical Method & the Vocation of Philosophy

Theory, Critical Method & the Vocation of Philosophy

Hegelian Dialectics & Ontology · 22 concepts · 26 talks · 33.5 hours · 2009–2026

The expert solves problems formulated by those in power; the true intellectual first questions whether the problem is correctly posed.

2009: 1 talk 2010: 2 talks 2011: 1 talk 2012: 1 talk 2013: 1 talk 2014: 3 talks 2015: 2 talks 2017: 1 talk 2019: 1 talk 2020: 1 talk 2022: 3 talks 2023: 2 talks 2024: 2 talks 2025: 3 talks 2026: 2 talks
≤2000talks carrying this idea, per year2026

In his words 5

“Our duty as theorists is to hurt people.”
“if facts don't fit theory so much worse for the facts”
“Theory is precisely the first step of theory is not to answer problems formulated by others, but to formulate the problem correctly.”

The stories that teach it

the jokes and anecdotes he reaches for when he works in this idea, ranked by how many of its talks they turn up in; each card is one story, with every retelling on its page

example · in 3 of its talks

Shouting at the TV during football

Žižek uses the image of shouting at a television during a match, 'boys!', knowing the players cannot hear you, as an analogy for the meaningless performativity of individual recycling gestures.

example · in 2 of its talks

Easier to imagine death of capitalism than death of Jameson

Žižek inverts Jameson's famous phrase as a eulogy: since Jameson lived until death 'happened to him,' it is now easier to imagine capitalism's end than Jameson's death.

example · in 3 of its talks

Santa Claus Belief

Parents deny believing in Santa while buying presents; children deny believing while pretending so as not to disappoint parents. No one believes in the first person yet the ritual functions perfectly.

example · in 2 of its talks

Breivik: anti-semitic and pro-Zionist simultaneously

Norwegian terrorist Breivik's manifesto is openly anti-semitic (Jews are a problem, Hitler did the work in Europe) yet simultaneously pro-Israel (support them there, just not here), exemplifying the logic of politically correct anti-immigration that uses the 'other' as a conve…

example · in 2 of its talks

James Bond Quantum of Solace, no sex at the end

Žižek notes that Quantum of Solace is the first Bond film where the love affair is not consummated, the protagonists simply split apart, as evidence that even Hollywood has abandoned the ideology of passionate love.

example · in 2 of its talks

Glasgow Climate Conference

The Glasgow conference said all the right things about acting now, yet things continued unchanged, illustrating the paradox of modern cynicism where speech replaces action.

Where it comes up 26

27 moments located in the transcripts, click a timestamp to play from there

1:44:48 expert vs. intellectual
… Interesting things happen in small so you here are in a good position because you are rich enough to resist the true horror which is called Bologna University reform which is one big attack on what Kant calls public use of reason.
~1:22:11 expert vs. intellectual
produce experts. But we if we are true intellectuals we are not experts. Experts are people who do what? Experts are people who solve problems defined by others. For example there are riots in Paris and police calls experts. How will be psychologically how will …
~0:01 expert vs. intellectual
Thanks very much, I am really honored to be here. Why? Because it's a general tendency in the so-called free Western world that academic institutions are more and more transformed into factories to produce experts. And if being an intellectual means anything today, it means …
~3:20 expert vs. intellectual
whose aim is to produce experts. Like I was debating Bologna Reform, this terrible European community [unintelligible] in France and a guy who later even wanted to become a minister gave me a wonderful example. He told me, this was a couple of years ago …
Interview with David Feldman2022-03-07 · 1:28:31
~1:07:43 productive hypocrisy
cynical realist although I don't consider myself cynical in any serious sense namely I still prefer this hypocritical strategy you know we must be for healthcare for all although we always find an excuse but hypocrisy at least opens up the way for criticism you …
4:28 productive force of partial, one-sided approach
… nterpretations the best readings of Hegel are those partial one-sided you take one aspect and you say that's the crucial thing I believe in productive force of partial one-sided approach okay but please please David first screw democracy democracy only works if there is a leader David are you the leader okay

The company it keeps

thought with
alongside works

Nearest in meaning

Concepts in this idea 22

4
expert vs. intellectual
The expert solves problems formulated by those in power; the true intellectual first questions whether the problem is correctly posed.
2
corrupting the youth
Via Badiou's reading of Socrates: philosophy's function is to undermine automatic trust in existing ideology, a positive value for Žižek.
2
expert opinion
A symptom of the crisis of scientific authority: once experts told us how things are, now they offer 'opinions', signaling that science has become an inconsistent field of competing perspectives rather than a source of stable truth.
2
productive hypocrisy
Hypocrisy is politically preferable to shameless openness because inconsistency gives opponents a foothold for critique; shameless openness forecloses all challenge.
1
crises as answers
His reversal of the question/answer relation: crises are not open questions but imposed answers; the critical task is to reconstruct the question to which the crisis is an answer.
1
critical but constructive dialogue
Žižek's ideal mode of discourse, contrasting with 'politically correct condemnations' that prevent listening.
1
criticopediology
The critical practice of questioning the formulation of a problem itself, rather than offering immediate solutions, as the first step toward a solution.
1
differential approach
The methodological axiom that analysis must include not only what is positively present in a phenomenon but also its negative determinations, what is absent but structurally implied.